Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Keeping the Well Full

This dashing young man is Ernest Hemingway as he looked during the 1920s when he was living in Paris, hopping from cafe to cafe to work on his writing. He's a man we would do well to emulate in many ways (well, aside from the whole multiple failed marriages, excessive alcohol consumption, and suicide thing). I read his memoir A Moveable Feast for book club last month and was surprised when I found little glints of wisdom that connected to my capstone projects. In this brief excerpt of his life, Hemingway recounts time he spent in Paris with his first wife Hadley, their son Bumby, and a host of other writers including F. Scott Fitzgerald, Gertrude Stein, and Ezra Pound. It's a very insightful book on the lives of many famous authors and their writing processes.

Aside from many entertaining side stories, Hemingway does delve into his writing process here and there. One point that struck me most was when he spoke of "never emptying the well" of your writing. He says, "I always worked until I had something done and I always stopped when I knew what was going to happen next. That way I could be sure of going on the next day." I was dismayed upon reading this to discover that I often let my well run dry and then wondered why I had such a difficult time the next day.

You see, Hemingway is one of those authors who tried his best to write every day. I usually roll my eyes at that bit of advice. "Of course," I'd think, "It's easy for him to write every day when he's lounging around Paris with a bunch of other talented writers and nothing else to do with his time than sit in a cafe and work." But then again, here we are, in a department full of other talented writers, with specific instructions to write as best we can for one whole semester, and two incredible professors dedicated to reading what we write and helping us improve upon it.

Our atmosphere couldn't be any better suited to write every day. And with that in mind, Hemingway's advice seems particularly wise. Whenever I sit down to write and find myself on a roll, I stay writing for as long as I possibly can, because who knows when it will come this easy again? But whenever I do that, inevitably, the next few times I try to write, there's nothing left. I've exhausted my creative supply. I think there's something to be said for writing small chunks every day, so long as we leave ourselves something to go on tomorrow.

Hemingway had one last piece of extraordinary advice: he said that when he wasn't writing, he would read and read and read so that he wasn't constantly thinking of his own writing and letting the well run dry. If we truly want to keep our writing fresh, we need to be continually reading new authors (or old favorites) to replenish the well. Sometimes that's the extra creative boost we need to keep going.

Do you find that capstone is leaving your well dry? Do you agree with Hemingway that it's better to stop when you know where you're going to go next? How does the quantity and quality of what you read affect what kind of writing you produce?

11 comments:

  1. i really like the well-run-dry image. i remember reading those lines in Moveable Feast (which Prof. McCann loaned to me over Christmas Break, thank you!)

    Another image for me is the marathon. When it comes to writing these days, i have lived too much by the deadline. So then i end up running 14 miles here, the day before the marathon, when i really should have been building up my muscles gradually. Sometimes i end the writing session dog-tired (well-run-dry). That doesn't make me wanna get out for a run when i get up the next morning.

    Or, if we wanna go with the age-old analogy of a relationship, you don't establish a good friendship with someone with an intense, joyful 4-hour coffee date every two-and-a-half weeks. That will get you some friendship. But even a few texts in between those two weeks, if not a quick bite to eat and a 20-minute phone call too, go a long way.

    So i'll have to try out Hemingway's advice, and get back to you.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've definitely let my well run dry. The only way to stay sane at this point is to just write when I can squeeze in the time, and more often than not, I'm already physically and emotionally exhausted. So, I start with a shallow well, and end with one sucked dry.
    I think I really need something to read to replenish the well; I'm waiting on a requested set of short stories from the library, and I'm really hoping those do it for me. I haven't been excited by anything I've read for quite a while.
    My question is, is it better to binge and purge, so to speak, while still leaving a bit in the bottom of the well at the end of the day? Will a barely damp well do? Has anyone ever tried this?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I remember hearing that bit of well running dry advice back in high school. For me I think it's been one of the best writing tips I've ever heard, but at the same time it's one of the hardest for me to keep. My tendency is always to write and write until I can't get anything more out, and then to come back to that writing as soon as I know what to say next, whether it's minutes later or months.

    I think the hard thing in Capstone for me is balancing the set hours. I keep feeling that I have to work on my projects for large chunks of time, but often when I do that I run out of ideas earlier than I had planned and spend a good ten or fifteen minutes reading and re-reading my poems, not having any idea what to do with them or how to finish revisions I've started. But if you can keep up with it and stick to it, I thiink Hemingway's advice is definitely worth keeping!

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is so excellent. I do feel that my well runs dry. Sometimes I am afraid that if I stop writing I will lose all the ideas in my head. They're usually not in chunks that I can put on shelves, but they are more like balloons floating away in every direction. If I don't anchor them down and spit them out onto a page right now, I might never get them back. I'm not sure that Hemingway's method would work for me, or if there's just something else I need to know about how my brain works. However, the reading aspect is absolutely something I can practically apply. I think I have this fear that I am going to sound too much like someone else when i read and then write, but the truth is....we haven't been writing all that long, and how developed can our own style really be yet? It's probably not that dangerous to immerse ourselves in others' words.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wonderful post! I really enjoyed this and have several thoughts... the first one being that Hadley is a gorgeous name and Bumby is not.

    Thank you for this peek into Hemingway's life. His writing process sounds like the speaker that came to Northwestern and did a Q&A in the Blue Room. I appreciate the intentionality behind writing well, to not leave until something good comes out and to start in the middle of someone direct so the next day doesn't start off in an abyss of uncertainty.

    Replenishing the well ... love that. It got me thinking about healthy writing, and how reading and practicing and giving our best is like vegetable writing but stressing rushing and giving whatever works is junk food writing.

    ReplyDelete
  6. A lot of times I find that when I am trying to write and am not "feeling it," the writing that comes out is pretty lackluster and all-around poor. However, coming back to that writing has sometimes helped spur on a fresh idea that I really love. Getting the boring stuff out lets me at least see it and then try to play with it (or have the beautiful feeling of just throwing it out all together, which always makes me feel like I have the freedom of a fresh slate).

    ReplyDelete
  7. Ashley, this was such a great post! Wow, it really hit upon a problem that I struggle with a lot. I love those times when I slide into the "easy" writing mode, where the words just keep flowing from my fingertips. Those moments don't come often, but it's awesome when they do. I really think I have a problem with letting the well run dry. I will just sit there and think about my story all day, and when I'm on a roll, I keep going, like you said. I've tried it once or twice where I stop writing in the middle of a sentence, but that usually drives me nuts. I'm one who needs to finish a thought before I can stop. Just like having to put a book down in the middle of a chapter bugs me. But maybe Hemingway was on to something. This is something I'll definitely have to try, considering it always seems like my well is dry every time I sit down to write.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good comments, everyone! I heard a famous writer (not being cagey--can't remember her name) that writer's block isn't a block so much as an emptiness. I think the antedote to the well running dry is to read and find a little being time too if we can. Sometimes pushing ahead with our writing when the well is dry and everything is grinding can do violence to our writing life--but perhaps it also builds a necessary perseverance.

      Delete
  8. I love that book. So much interesting detail and beautiful images of the places he visited and lived in. I also distinctly remember that part where he said he never left work until he had something done and always stopped when he knew what was going to happen next - such a wonderful idea when it comes to writing. And any work in general I suppose.

    I think I fairly easily let my well run dry. It's always so amazing to me that after I start reading a book - even just a few chapters - I want to blog or write poetry or tell a story. I wonder why God made us that way, to be like wells or outpourings. Why do we recycle inspiration? I wonder what that means in the big scheme of everything.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I don't think that leaving a bit of an idea at the bottom of your well guarantees that it will fill up again the next day. I've had days where I save what I think is a good start for the next day, but when I start on it, I find out that I run dry anyway. Maybe it is because I don't spend as much time reading as I should anymore. Maybe I'll find that the secret to keeping the well full is not to let it keep filling itself, but to work on filling it myself.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Oh, boy, I think consistency matters hugely! Sort of greases all the gears, keeps things working for when you really need to crank out some stuff...
    I let my well run dry a lot just by not emptying and filling it consistently; instead I want to just use it a lot or a little whenever I feel like. I think discipline is the hardest, most important thing about being a writer, and I'm not convinced I have that yet.
    Thanks for sharing!

    ReplyDelete